Building a website is one of the first steps in establishing a digital presence for your business or personal brand. In today’s world, there are countless tools available that allow you to create a website on your own. From DIY website builders with ready-made templates to custom-built websites designed by professionals, the options can be overwhelming.

At some point, you’ll likely find yourself asking: is it time to move from a template to a custom-built website? The answer depends on several factors, including the goals of your site, your budget, and your long-term vision. In this post, we'll explore the key differences between DIY and done-for-you websites, and help you decide when it's time to upgrade to a custom website.

The DIY Route: Building a Website with Templates

DIY website templates have democratized web design, allowing people with no coding experience to create a website in just a few hours. These templates are available on platforms like WordPress, Squarespace, and Wix, and they provide a convenient way to build a website quickly and inexpensively. While there are many benefits to this option, it also comes with limitations.

Benefits of Using a DIY Website Template

Low Cost: One of the biggest appeals of DIY website templates is the price. Most website builder platforms offer free or affordable plans, making them ideal for individuals or small businesses with limited budgets.
Quick Setup: Building a website with a template can be completed quickly, often in a matter of hours. Many templates come with pre-designed layouts, so all you need to do is add your content and tweak the colors and fonts to match your brand.
Ease of Use: DIY website builders typically don’t require any coding knowledge, making them accessible for beginners. With drag-and-drop functionality and pre-designed elements, you can create a website that looks polished without any technical expertise.
Customization (to an Extent): While templates offer customization options such as color schemes, fonts, and content blocks, they are still relatively restrictive. You're working within a set structure and may not be able to make significant changes to the layout or functionality of the site.

Challenges of Using DIY Templates

While DIY websites are great for getting started, they may not be enough as your business or brand grows. Templates come with certain limitations that can hold back the full potential of your website.

Limited Branding: Customization options with templates can only go so far. Templates are made for the masses, so your site might end up looking similar to others using the same template. This can make it harder for you to differentiate your brand in a competitive marketplace.
Scaling Issues: As your business grows, you may need advanced features like e-commerce functionality, membership areas, or complex forms. Many templates aren’t built to handle this level of complexity, and scaling may require switching to a different template or platform, which can be time-consuming and costly.
Lack of Uniqueness: Templates are often used by countless other websites, meaning that even with minor tweaks, your site may still look very similar to others. This lack of uniqueness can hurt your brand’s identity and impact its ability to stand out.
Limited SEO and Speed Optimization: Some DIY templates don’t have optimized code, which can impact the speed and SEO of your site. Slow loading times and poor search engine rankings can ultimately drive visitors away.

The Done-for-You Route: Custom-Built Websites

A custom-built website is designed specifically for your business, giving you complete control over every aspect of its design, layout, functionality, and performance. While custom websites are typically more expensive and time-consuming to create, they offer a range of benefits that make them worth considering as your brand evolves.

Benefits of a Custom Website

Tailored Design: A custom-built website is designed with your unique brand in mind. Every design element, from the color palette to the layout, is created to reflect your company’s personality and values. This ensures that your website stands out and aligns with your brand identity.
Scalability: A custom website is built to grow with your business. Whether you need more advanced features, additional pages, or integrations, a custom-built site can easily be updated to meet your evolving needs. Custom websites are more flexible and scalable, allowing for future growth without hitting roadblocks.
Advanced Features: Unlike templates, which often come with pre-set functions, custom websites allow you to add any features you need. This could include custom e-commerce solutions, booking systems, member areas, or any other functionality specific to your business. With a custom-built site, you have full control over the features you include.
Better SEO and Speed Optimization: Custom-built websites are typically coded with SEO best practices in mind, meaning they are more likely to rank well in search engines. Additionally, a custom site can be optimized for faster load times, which is crucial for both user experience and SEO.
Unique User Experience: A custom website can be designed with the best user experience (UX) in mind, guiding visitors smoothly through the site and encouraging conversions. This is especially important for businesses that rely on lead generation or e-commerce sales.
Long-Term Investment: While a custom website requires a higher initial investment, it is often a better long-term investment. Custom sites are built to last, and they can be updated and improved as your business grows.

Challenges of a Custom Website

Higher Cost: Custom websites are more expensive than DIY templates. The cost can vary depending on the complexity of the design and the features you need, but it is generally much higher than a DIY template option.
Longer Development Time: A custom-built website requires more time to develop compared to a template-based website. This means more upfront time investment to get your site up and running.
Need for Ongoing Maintenance: Custom websites typically require more ongoing maintenance, whether it’s for updating the software, adding new content, or ensuring security. This can either be done by your team or outsourced to a developer.

When to Upgrade from a Template to a Custom Website

Deciding when to upgrade from a template to a custom website depends on several factors. Here are some signs it may be time to consider the switch:

Your Business is Growing: If your website is starting to outgrow its template and you need more advanced features or functionality, it’s a sign that you might need a custom solution.
Your Branding Needs to Stand Out: If you find that your template is too limiting and doesn’t reflect your brand’s personality, a custom website can give you the unique design you need.
You Need Scalability: If you’re planning to expand your business and need a website that can grow with you, a custom-built website is the best choice.
You Want Better Performance: If your template is holding you back in terms of speed, SEO, and user experience, investing in a custom website can improve these factors significantly.
Your Business is Professional and You Want to Compete: As your business becomes more established, you may want to look more professional and credible to your customers. A custom-built website can elevate your brand and help you compete with others in your industry.

Conclusion

Both DIY website templates and custom-built websites have their pros and cons. DIY templates are great for individuals or small businesses just getting started, but they can become limiting as your needs evolve. On the other hand, custom-built websites offer greater flexibility, scalability, and unique branding, but they come at a higher cost and require more time and resources to develop.

Ultimately, the decision to upgrade from a template to a custom website depends on your business goals, budget, and long-term vision. If you're ready to take your website and brand to the next level, a custom website is worth the investment.

For more information on how to take your website to new heights, click here to learn more about custom website design and when it’s time for an upgrade!

Explore More Blogs from The Growth Passport

Featured

5 Must-Have Website Features for Wellness Coaches and Practitioners

Wellness coaches and practitioners need specific website features to streamline their business and attract clients. Learn about the must-have elements and how custom Squarespace design can elevate your online presence.